In the world of craft beer, a big problem is emerging that could shake things up1. Liquor liability insurance costs are skyrocketing, risking the future of many brew pubs and distilleries. The big question is, what’s behind this spike in Brew Pub Insurance Costs? And how can owners deal with these higher costs?
Key Takeaways
- Liquor liability insurance costs have skyrocketed, with premiums increasing by as much as 40% in just one year1.
- Legislation mandating minimum $1 million coverage for businesses serving alcohol has led to insurance companies paying out more than they’re taking in, causing an exodus of underwriters1.
- The lack of competition in the insurance market has allowed remaining companies to significantly raise premiums, putting a financial strain on small businesses1.
- Joint and several liability laws have been identified as a significant contributor to the escalating costs, and legislative reform is crucial1.
- Comprehensive liability insurance reforms are necessary to protect small-business owners from exorbitant insurance costs1.
The Brewing Crisis: Skyrocketing Insurance Premiums
In South Carolina, the restaurant and bar industry faces a serious threat because of rising brew pub insurance premiums. Many establishments could close down2. This issue started in 2017 when the state said bars and restaurants must have liability insurance worth $1 million yearly2. Since then, many insurance companies left, making the costs of insurance go up a lot2.
The effect of these higher prices is huge2. For example, a bar in Myrtle Beach went from $55,000 in 2022 to $145,000 in 20232. Likewise, in Columbia, a restaurant’s insurance climbed from $30,000 to $150,000 a year2. When Smiley’s in Greenville couldn’t afford their insurance anymore, they had to shut down. Their insurance went from about $6,000 in 2020 to over $22,000 last year. This year, it’s expected to be $55,0002.
The law in South Carolina, called joint and several liability, is a main reason for the high insurance premiums2. This law says if an impaired person causes harm within 12 hours of being at a place, that place could be fully or partly responsible2. This law affects the one in 12 jobs related to the hospitality industry in South Carolina. It’s not just the bars and restaurants that feel the effect. It’s like a wave that touches many areas2.
The Impact of Joint and Several Liability Laws
The law in South Carolina is a key reason insurance prices for bars and restaurants are going up2. Because of this law, places that serve alcohol can be fully or partly responsible for any harm an impaired person causes2. Insurance companies are facing big losses. As a result, insurance providers are leaving the state. This leaves bar and restaurant owners with fewer choices and much higher insurance costs3.
A new proposal called the Justice Act wants to change how responsibility is assigned. It suggests that places would only be responsible for the harm they truly caused, not for everything that happens3. South Carolina has a high rate of drunk driving incidents, which doesn’t help. It’s one of the top ten states in drunk driving deaths in the nation3. This also plays a part in the high insurance costs for bars and restaurants in the state.
The situation in South Carolina’s restaurant and bar scene is very tough. The rising brew pub insurance premiums are hitting hard, leading many places to close. This is not just hurting the bars and restaurants; it’s affecting the whole state’s economy2. People are working hard to come up with solutions. However, the future of this important sector is still unclear234.
The Crux of the Matter: Joint and Several Liability
The main issue with rising insurance costs for brew pubs is joint and several liability. This rule states that if a business is sued and loses, it might have to pay the full settlement. This is true even if there were other businesses at fault in the lawsuit5. As a result, insurance prices have shot up for restaurants and bars. They could be on the hook for what a customer does, no matter how little they’re at fault5.
With joint and several liability, a person can get the full amount from any of the accused parties. This is so even if that party had only a small part in the wrong. So, a business could end up paying most of the damages, even if they are barely to blame5. This is a big issue for brew pubs and bars. They might have to pay for what a customer does, regardless of how responsible they are. This makes things very tough for them.
The alcohol industry faces especially high risks because of joint and several liability. Such businesses could be accountable if an intoxicated person harms themselves or someone else. This extra risk has caused insurance costs to go up a lot for brew pubs and bars. And this makes it hard for them to keep running smoothly5.
| Liability Scenario | Liability Outcome |
|---|---|
| Patron A, who is visibly intoxicated, causes a car accident that injures Patron B. | The brew pub that served Patron A could be held fully liable, even if Patron A was primarily responsible for the accident. |
| Patron C suffers a slip-and-fall injury at the brew pub due to a wet floor. | The brew pub could be held liable for the entire damages, even if the wet floor was not the primary cause of the accident. |
| Patron D, who is underage, consumes alcohol at the brew pub and later causes property damage. | The brew pub could be held responsible for the damages, despite having minimal or no culpability. |
These examples show the big risks that brew pubs and bars face. They lead to higher insurance costs and can even threaten the survival of these businesses. Joint and several liability is a key reason for the difficult situation these businesses are in6
Escalating Costs and the Lack of Competition
The crisis in brew pubs and restaurants has worsened due to insurance market problems7. A law in 2017 made it mandatory for all serving alcohol after 5 p.m. to have at least $1 million in insurance7. Because of little competition, insurance companies raised their prices. This made it hard for many places to buy the needed insurance7.
The Ripple Effect on Communities
High insurance costs are forcing some places to close, affecting local people8. In the UK, beloved pubs are shutting down, leaving empty spaces in communities. From January to June 2023, 383 pubs in the UK closed8. The heart of these communities is disappearing, causing a great loss8.
When these places close, it’s more than just about losing a spot to gather9. A European report shows pubs and restaurants are vital for local growth and jobs9. If these places shut down, it will hurt the economy. It means fewer jobs and less tax money for the area9.
“The closure of these establishments has a ripple effect on the local communities, as they lose special places that are integral to the fabric of the community.”
The rising insurance costs threaten all kinds of local businesses7. Without affordable insurance, brew pubs and shops might not survive. This harms community life and local culture7. We must find solutions to save these businesses. Their well-being means a lot to the communities they are part of7.
Rising Brew Pub Insurance Costs: A Burden on Small Businesses
The costs of insurance for brew pubs are going up fast, making it hard for small business owners. They find it tough to stay open as they deal with rising insurance prices. To cope, many have to increase their prices, making customers spend less. This drop in revenue is hurting these businesses10.
Insurance for microbreweries can cost between $500 and $1,500 monthly. They need at least $1 million in general liability insurance per incident10. Also, they should have $2 million in total coverage. As their size and activities grow, so do their insurance costs. Even with options from companies like Allstate, Travelers, and The Hartford, these costs are a big problem for small businesses10.
Small and medium-sized businesses are feeling the weight of rising insurance prices. In late 2021, premiums went up by 10.6% for medium businesses and 6.3% for small ones. Bar owners in South Carolina, for example, have been hit hard. Their liquor liability costs have soared. In just three years, bills went from $8,800 to over $31,000 and from $5,000 to $60,00011.
The insurance market lacks competition, and some companies are even leaving certain states because of high costs11. This makes things even tougher for small business owners. They face revenue drops and the possible shutting down of community favorites.
To combat these increasing costs, small business owners must look into risk management. This can include things like cleaning up on social media and reviewing policies closely11. These proactive steps can safeguard the future of these important community places.
The Urgent Need for Legislative Action
Brew pub insurance costs are soaring, needing immediate legal help. The South Carolina Justice Act is our best bet for change now12. It wants to decide payouts based on fault shares. This bill is key to start helping the industry out12.
Yet, more steps might be needed to fix the bigger issue of unfair liability costs. The Act is a good first move. But, other laws might be necessary to deal with the main problems causing insurance costs to go up12.
The South Carolina Justice Act and Lawsuit Reform
The South Carolina Justice Act could be a big help if it passes. It looks to stop big payouts that raise insurance prices. This way, it tries to make things fairer for brew pubs12.
Acts to reform lawsuits, like the South Carolina Justice Act, are very important. They aim to fix the legal system and ease the brewing industry’s worries12. As it moves forward, everyone needs to support this bill for it to make a difference12.
Though the Act is a good step, the brewing industry still needs to push for more changes. These changes, along with dealing with what’s making insurance rates go up, are necessary. They will be keys to helping brew pubs for the long haul12.
“Urgent legislative action is needed to address the rising brew pub insurance costs. The best hope for reform in the current legislative session is the South Carolina Justice Act, which would apportion damages according to the percentage of fault.”
The South Carolina Justice Act and others like it are vital for the brewing industry. They aim to share the liability fairly. This approach would lower the high insurance costs for brew pubs. It steps towards making the legal system fairer for them12.
Liability Insurance: A Broader Issue
The cost of brew pub Liability Insurance is rising in South Carolina. Governor Henry McMaster wants to reform joint and several liability rules. The South Carolina Coalition for Lawsuit Reform supports these changes13.
The South Carolina Justice Act is the first step in helping. But, more steps might be needed. The high prices of liquor liability insurance are forcing some bars and restaurants to close1314.
The South Carolina Bar and Tavern Association wants urgent changes. It’s made of bar and brewery owners and insurance agents. They’ve gathered over a thousand signatures for reform14. They plan to present these to the governor and lawmakers on June 18.
Dealing with Broader Business Liability Issues is tough. Everyone involved must find answers. The goal is to keep businesses safe but with fair insurance rates15.
Every industry in South Carolina is feeling the weight of high Liability Insurance prices. As we face these challenges, it’s clear we need to change. Everyone must work together for real and lasting solutions131415.
Factors Driving Insurance Rate Hikes
The brewing industry is seeing insurance costs go way up. It’s vital for brewery owners and managers to know why. They need to find ways to handle these rising costs to keep their businesses safe.
Expensive Risks and Social Inflation
Insurance companies face many expensive risks today. This comes from things like global issues, a tough job market, bad weather, and rising prices16.
But, what’s really making costs soar for insurers is social inflation. This is when legal settlements and jury awards get more expensive. So, insurance companies feel the heat to raise premiums to balance their books16.
The Impact of Reinsurance Costs
On top of social inflation, reinsurance costs are also going up. Reinsurance helps spread the risk for insurers. But, especially in the casualty market, this cost is growing17. This adds to the reasons why insurance premiums are rising for breweries.
| Metric | Value |
|---|---|
| Auto insurance premium increase | 20% to 25%18 |
| Projected average annual auto insurance cost in 2024 | $1,98417 |
| States with highest projected auto insurance premium increases | Nevada (28%), Washington, Arizona, Connecticut, Louisiana, Georgia (16-18%)17 |
| Savings from shopping around for auto insurance | Average of $398 per year17 |
| Savings from bundling home and auto insurance | 18%17 |
| Savings from using a telematics device | Up to 30%17 |
The growing complexity of these challenges is evident. What’s needed are smart solutions. Plus, we might even see changes in policies to help small firms and their local areas deal with these costs.
Exploring Insurance Coverage for Restaurants
Being a restaurant owner means you need good insurance. It helps protect your business from risks. Main types of insurance are general liability and commercial property. Often, you can get both in a Business Owner’s Policy (BOP)19. A BOP’s cost for a restaurant might range from $1,100 to $10,500 per year. This varies based on the restaurant’s location, its equipment, and other important factors19.
Essential Policies and Cost Considerations
General liability insurance protects against claims from injuries or damages on your property. Commercial property insurance covers your building, equipment, and stock20. Having these can protect your restaurant from accidents or lawsuits. They guard against events that might harm your business20.
Restaurants might also need workers’ compensation, commercial auto, liquor liability, and cyber liability insurance19. The cost of these varies. It depends on your business’s size, what it does, and its risk level19.
| Insurance Policy | Average Monthly Premium | Coverage Highlights |
|---|---|---|
| Business Owner’s Policy (BOP) | $135 | Includes general liability and commercial property coverage, with options for food spoilage protection up to $100,000. |
| Workers’ Compensation | Varies by state | Covers medical expenses and partial lost wages for work-related injuries. |
| Commercial Auto | Varies by vehicle | Protects your business-owned vehicles in the event of accidents. |
| Liquor Liability | Varies by state | Covers risks associated with serving alcohol, such as property damage or injury caused by intoxicated customers. |
| Cyber Liability | Varies by coverage | Protects your business from costs related to cyber attacks or data breaches, including customer notification expenses. |
It’s crucial for restaurant owners to look into what insurance they need. Knowing the costs helps in making smart choices. By working with trusted insurance providers, you can get the right coverage at a good price19.
The right insurance keeps your restaurant safe from unexpected dangers. Exploring different insurance types and their costs helps you protect your business. It ensures your restaurant can thrive for a long time201921.
Bar Insurance: Navigating Higher Risks
Insuring a bar or tavern is more costly than a restaurant. This is because they serve alcohol, leading to greater risks22. Liquor liability insurance is key for bars. It helps if someone gets hurt or property is damaged due to drunk customers23. Bars also need higher levels of general liability and workers’ compensation. This is due to the extra risks tied to their operations23.
For bars, insurance costs average around $4,000 yearly. This includes a Business Owner’s Policy, workers’ comp, and liquor insurance24. The price can change based on where the bar is, its size, and its insurance history. The chosen coverage limits and deductions also matter.
Bars are unique because they face specific risks. Having liquor liability insurance is crucial. It shields the bar from claims if a drunk customer gets hurt or hurts others23. General liability insurance deals with injury or damage to a third party. Workers’ compensation helps employees who get hurt or sick on the job23.
Along with these, bars might need special policies. These include spoilage insurance for food loss, assault and battery insurance for legal defense in fights, and cyber liability for data leaks23.
| Insurance Coverage | Purpose |
|---|---|
| Liquor Liability Insurance | Protects against claims from intoxicated patrons causing harm |
| General Liability Insurance | Covers third-party bodily injury and property damage |
| Workers’ Compensation Insurance | Provides coverage for employee injuries sustained on the job |
| Spoilage Insurance | Protects against loss of perishable inventory |
| Assault & Battery Insurance | Covers legal costs associated with patron altercations |
| Cyber Liability Insurance | Protects against data breaches and related liabilities |
Understanding and meeting a bar’s insurance needs is tough but essential. With the right coverages and a good insurance partner, bar owners can keep their place safe and running smoothly despite the challenges222324.
Finding the Right Insurance Provider
Choosing the best insurance for your Finding the Right Insurance Provider or Selecting Restaurant Insurance matters a lot. Having a skilled insurance advisor helps a bunch. They will walk you through different coverage options. This ensures your business is well protected25.
Experts in insuring breweries and restaurants understand your specific challenges. They offer solutions from liability to workers’ comp and more. You get what you need without overpaying25.
Tons of things can impact your insurance costs, like your place’s size and how much beer you make26. An insurance pro who knows your industry will help find the best deals for you25.
Making beer brings unique risks, like dealing with storage and serving food26. A good insurance agent will spot these and set you up with the right policies. They make sure your place stays safe25.
Some insurance companies offer special savings for things like medical plans. Keeping your brewery secure and in line with regulations can lower your costs25.
Pick an insurance company known for helping your type of business. See what others say about them. Getting the right coverage means looking at options and getting recommendations25.
Your insurance advisor is more than just a helper. They’re a key partner in running your brewery or restaurant. They make sure you’re covered while you focus on making your business better25.
“The right insurance coverage can make all the difference in safeguarding your brew pub or restaurant. Work with an experienced provider who understands the unique needs of your industry.”
Conclusion
In South Carolina, the brewing industry faces a big problem with high brew pub insurance costs27. These costs go up mainly because of laws around liability and the lack of insurance market competition27. Many restaurants and bars have had to shut down, hurting the local area a lot27. Quick action is needed, like passing the South Carolina Justice Act, to fix the insurance situation27.
Brew pub owners should know why their insurance rates are going up. This includes costly risks, social inflation, and reinsurance costs28. They can help protect their businesses by looking into the right insurance coverage28. This means checking out key policies for restaurants and bars28.
The brewing industry in South Carolina is still dealing with these tough times27. Business owners need to stay updated, push for new laws, and find good insurance partners272928. Doing these things can help them deal with higher insurance costs and keep their businesses running27. By working together, they can get through this challenge and help keep South Carolina’s tourism and hospitality scene lively27.
FAQ
What are the key factors driving the rising costs of brew pub insurance?
How have joint and several liability laws contributed to the insurance crisis in the brewing industry?
What is the impact of the lack of competition in the insurance market on brew pub insurance costs?
What are the key legislative actions being taken to address the rising brew pub insurance costs?
How can brew pub owners manage the increased costs of insurance premiums?
Source Links
- https://greenvillejournal.com/eat-drink/skyrocketing-insurance-costs-are-closing-bars-businesses-will-sc-act-in-2024/ – Skyrocketing insurance costs are closing bars, businesses. Will SC act in 2024?
- https://upstatebusinessjournal.com/eat-drink/sc-bars-reach-crisis-point-with-skyrocketing-liability-insurance-rates/ – SC bars reach ‘crisis point’ with skyrocketing liability insurance rates
- https://charlestoncitypaper.com/2024/02/18/bar-owners-struggle-as-legislators-search-for-solutions/ – Bar owners struggle as legislators search for solutions – Charleston City Paper
- https://scvenuecrisis.org/inthenews/ – The Latest News
- https://digitalcommons.osgoode.yorku.ca/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1644&context=ohlj – Strict Products Liability Revisited
- https://subscription.westacademic.com/Book/Detail?id=26249&q=sum and substance torts – Study Aids Collection | Book
- https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4193508/ – Washington State Health Services Act: Implementing Comprehensive Health Care Reform
- https://www.linkedin.com/posts/peter-cronin-33b9a2b_the-great-british-pub-activity-7118128230800236544-mV3h – Peter Cronin on LinkedIn: The great British pub. | 38 comments
- http://aei.pitt.edu/85784/1/V.4.V.pdf – ECONOMIES OF SCALE : IMPACT ON COMPETITION AND SCALE EFFECTS
- https://smartfinancial.com/brewery-insurance – Qualify for a Brewery Insurance Program To Protect Your Business | SmartFinancial
- https://www.crcgroup.com/Tools-Intel/post/liquor-liability-market-challenging-for-many-in-2023 – No title found
- https://iapp.org/resources/article/global-legislative-predictions/ – IAPP Global Legislative Predictions 2024
- https://www.wyff4.com/article/brewery-closes-liquor-liability-south-carolina/61082598 – Another Upstate brewery, restaurant will close due to liquor liability insurance costs
- https://www.statehousereport.com/2024/06/14/more-news-new-group-looks-to-lower-liquor-liability-costs/ – New group looks to lower liquor liability costs – Statehouse Report
- https://www.postandcourier.com/opinion/commentary/south-carolina-restaurants-insurance-politics-pawns/article_c184b290-fd97-11ee-8687-2b82761cae1b.html – Hicks: Everyone’s a victim in the Legislature’s liquor liability insurance politics
- https://programbusiness.com/blog/brewery-insurance-liability-programs-costs-more – Brewery Insurance: Liability, Programs, Costs & More – ProgramBusiness | Where insurance industry clicks
- https://www.alliedinsmgr.com/2024-auto-insurance-premium-increase – Auto Insurance Premiums Set to Increase in 2024
- https://www.city-journal.org/article/how-government-is-driving-auto-insurance-rates-higher – How Government Is Driving Auto Insurance Rates Higher
- https://www.insureon.com/food-business-insurance/business-owners-policy – Business Owner’s Policy (BOP) for Restaurants and Other Food Businesses | Insureon
- https://www.mynewmarkets.com/articles/184302/south-carolina-liquor-liability-market-extremely-unprofitable-doi-report-says – South Carolina Liquor Liability Market ‘Extremely Unprofitable,’ DOI Report Says
- https://pos.toasttab.com/blog/on-the-line/restaurant-variable-fixed-costs – Control Restaurant Fixed Costs and Variable Costs to Protect Profits
- https://programbusiness.com/blog/brewery-insurance-liability-programs-costs-more/ – Brewery Insurance: Liability, Programs, Costs & More – ProgramBusiness | Where insurance industry clicks
- https://www.mfeinsurance.com/bar-insurance/ – Bar Insurance – MFE Insurance Brokerage
- https://www.investopedia.com/articles/personal-finance/011216/economics-owning-bar.asp – The Economics of Owning a Bar
- https://breweryinsuranceprogram.com/ – Home – Brewery Insurance Program – Total Coverage for Breweries and Brewpubs
- https://www.ramsburginsurance.com/blog/your-options-for-brewery-insurance-in-the-craft-beverage-space.aspx – Your Options for Brewery Insurance in the Craft Beverage Space
- https://www.lexingtonchronicle.com/stories/restaurant-owners-strategize-around-rising-insurance-rates-seek-help-from-sc-lawmakers,80814 – Restaurant owners strategize around rising insurance rates, seek help from SC lawmakers – Lexington County Chronicle
- https://www.insurancejournal.com/news/southeast/2023/09/18/740648.htm – South Carolina Bars, Eateries Closing Down for Lack of Affordable Liability Coverage
- https://scdailygazette.com/2024/02/15/bar-owners-say-insurance-costs-are-driving-them-out-of-business-legislators-consider-changes/ – Bar owners say insurance costs are driving them out of business. Legislators consider changes. • SC Daily Gazette
